According to the U.S. Census Bureau, there are more than 51.6 million Black or African Americans in the United States as of 2024. Texas has the largest state population, while Cook County, Illinois has the largest county population. This means that many households face the same question every spring: who should prepare my taxes, and can I trust them? For many Black families, this question carries extra weight. Using tax year 2014 data, researchers at the Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research estimated that Black taxpayers were audited roughly 2.9 to 4.7 times more often than non-Black taxpayers — a reminder that getting the return right matters.
Here's the thing: Whoever signs your tax return has significant influence over your financial life. A competent tax preparer can identify credits for which you qualify and prevent you from getting into trouble. However, a careless or dishonest one could cost you money, your refund and sometimes much more besides.
The IRS reported 840,554 active PTIN holders as of September 2, 2025, according to the National Association of Enrolled Agents. But not all of them carry the same training or the same obligations. This guide explains what a tax preparer actually does, how to tell the qualified ones from the risky ones, and how the rules differ depending on where you live.
Key takeaways
- Anyone who is paid to prepare a federal tax return must have a Preparer Tax Identification Number (PTIN) from the IRS.
- For the 2026 filing season, the total PTIN fee was $18.75, comprising a $10 fee for the IRS and an $8.75 fee for the contractor (IRS, 2025).
- The level of training and rights before the IRS varies widely among credentials — enrolled agents, CPAs and attorneys have the most.
- According to IRC § 6694, for tax years 2025 and 2026 a preparer may be subject to a penalty equal to the greater of $1,000 or 50% of their income from the return for a return containing an unreasonable position (IRS, 2024).
- The state rules differ sharply. For example, California, Oregon, Maryland and New York each regulate paid preparers in their own way.
Table of Contents
What does a tax preparer actually do?
At its most basic, a tax preparer is someone you pay to complete and submit your federal income tax return. However, the role involves more than just entering numbers into software.
A good interviewer asks questions. They want to know if you've had a baby, started a side hustle, bought a home or sent a child to college, because each of these changes the credits and deductions you can claim. They organize your W-2s, 1099s and receipts correctly. They submit your return via the IRS e-file system, which is used by most preparers. And when the refund arrives, or a notice arrives months later, a reliable preparer will still be there to explain it.
Most paid preparers now file electronically. Through May 2, 2025, tax professionals had e-filed 74.445 million individual returns — about 53.6% of all e-filed returns — while taxpayers filed 64.478 million themselves, according to the IRS. So more than half of e-filed returns come from a professional.
One rule applies to every single paid preparer. Anyone who is paid to prepare federal returns must have a preparer tax identification number, or PTIN. For the 2025 filing season the application or renewal fee was $19.75, and for the 2026 season it dropped to $18.75, with every PTIN expiring on December 31 of its issued year (IRS, 2025). Treasury Decision 10035, effective September 30, 2025, cut the IRS portion of that fee to $10, with a separate $8.75 contractor fee making up the 2026 total, according to the Department of the Treasury.
Different credentials, plainly explained
Not all preparers are the same, and the letters after someone's name can reveal a lot about them.
An enrolled agent is a tax preparer who is licensed directly by the federal government and has passed a rigorous IRS exam or worked for the agency. Enrolled agents can represent you before the IRS on any matter. A certified public accountant (CPA) is licensed by a state board and often handles accounting and business work alongside tax returns. Attorneys specializing in tax law have the broadest legal rights of all.
Then there are preparers who have completed the IRS's Annual Filing Season Program. According to the IRS, for the 2025 and 2026 filing seasons, non-exempt participants generally needed 18 hours of IRS-approved education — a six-hour refresher course and test, 10 hours of federal tax law and two hours of ethics. Those exempt from the refresher course needed 15 hours. While it's not a full license, it demonstrates that the individual is keeping their training up to date.
The breakdown reflects this range. According to the National Association of Enrolled Agents, of the active PTIN holders in 2025, there were approximately 207,820 CPAs, 26,815 attorneys, 63,705 enrolled agents, and 73,454 Annual Filing Season Program record holders. Some individuals held more than one credential. This leaves a significant proportion of preparers with only a PTIN.
Why does this matter? Because the rights of representation differ. If the IRS questions your return, an enrolled agent, certified public accountant (CPA) or attorney can represent you. A preparer with only a PTIN generally cannot. The low federal baseline for preparer training can be traced back in part to a 2014 ruling. In Loving v. IRS, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit ruled that federal law did not permit the IRS to force all return preparers to undergo mandatory competency and continuing education. Consequently, the baseline remained low and you were left with the burden of making the right choice.
Need a Black accountant? Heritage Web can connect you.
Where you live changes the rules
Federal rules set the minimum standard. Some states build a lot on top of them, and this is where things get tricky.
California is one of the strictest states. According to the California Franchise Tax Board, non-exempt preparers serving tax year 2025 returns in 2026 must register with the California Tax Education Council, complete a 60-hour qualifying course, hold a PTIN and maintain a $5,000 bond. Annual renewal requires 20 hours of education, a $33 registration fee, and a $2 processing fee.
Oregon goes even further. According to the Oregon Board of Tax Practitioners, a licensed tax preparer must complete 80 hours of approved education, pass a state exam and work under an authorized supervisor for those handling tax year 2025 returns in 2026.
Other states regulate differently. In Maryland, non-exempt individual preparers serving tax year 2025 returns in 2026 generally must pass a state examination — a $78 fee, with a passing score of 70% — and register for a two-year period, according to the Maryland Department of Labor. In New York, commercial preparers who meet the state's 10-return threshold and serve tax year 2025 returns in 2026 pay a $100 annual registration fee and must complete applicable education, according to the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance. For Illinois taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2017, paid preparers must enter their federal PTIN on state returns — a reporting rule rather than a separate license, according to the Illinois Department of Revenue.
The message is clear: check with your own state's revenue or licensing agency, because what constitutes legitimacy in one state may not apply in another.
Warning signs you should never ignore
Most preparers are honest. However, those who are not can cause serious damage, and certain patterns tend to recur.
- They won't give you their PTIN or sign the return. Every paid preparer must sign the return and include their PTIN. If a preparer leaves the signature line blank, this is a red flag.
- They promise you a large refund before they have even seen your documents. No honest tax preparer can guarantee an outcome. The amount of your refund depends on your actual figures.
- They charge a percentage of your refund as a fee. This creates an incentive to inflate credits illegally.
- They want the refund to be sent to their account. It should be sent to you.
These aren't hypothetical concerns. According to IRS Criminal Investigation, the agency opened 190 abusive-preparer cases in fiscal year 2024, recommending 91 prosecutions and recording 84 sentencings. Furthermore, the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration identified over 38,000 preparers who used non-compliant PTINs on more than 2.2 million returns in the 2025 processing year.
The law is on your side here. According to the IRS, under IRC § 6694, for tax years 2025 and 2026, a preparer who takes an unreasonable position can face a penalty of the greater of $1,000 or 50% of the income from that return. Willful or reckless conduct raises this penalty to the greater of $5,000 or 75%. Under IRC § 7216, a preparer who knowingly misuses or discloses your tax information without authorization can face criminal charges. Treat your data and signature with the legal weight they carry.
The refund add-ons that quietly cost you
Be careful with extras at tax time. Many tax preparers offer refund anticipation checks and similar products that allow you to pay the fees out of your refund rather than upfront. Convenient? Yes. Free? No.
According to the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration, for the 2023 tax year, approximately 21.9 million of the 138 million e-filed tax returns used a refund-related product, and around 96% of these used a refund anticipation check. The agency estimated that more than $842 million was paid in refund anticipation check fees alone — on top of the preparation fee. This money is taken directly from refunds.
The average refund through May 2, 2025 was $2,947 across all refunds, according to the IRS. When fees nibble at that, it adds up fast across a neighborhood. Ask for the full cost in writing before you agree to anything.
Credits, due diligence and finding someone you trust
If you claim certain tax credits, your tax preparer has a special legal responsibility. According to IRC § 6695(g), a preparer must demonstrate that they have exercised due diligence if a return claims the Earned Income Tax Credit, the Child Tax Credit, the American Opportunity Tax Credit or Head of Household status. According to the IRS, Revenue Procedure 2024-40 set the penalty at $650 per failure for returns filed in 2026, and Revenue Procedure 2025-32 raised it to $665 per failure for returns filed in 2027. So, if a preparer asks you detailed questions about your children or your household, it is because they are acting in accordance with the law, not because they are being nosy.
When choosing a tax accountant, ask the following questions directly: What is your PTIN? What credentials do you hold? Will you represent me if the IRS has any questions? How do you charge? A preparer who answers these questions plainly is showing you respect.
There is also free help available. According to Howard University, its School of Business runs a Volunteer Income Tax Assistance site, supported in part by the Metro DC chapter of the National Association of Black Accountants, which offers both in-person and virtual tax return preparation services in 2025. Programs like these demonstrate how community institutions can provide support where trust and cost are significant barriers.
Your next step
The right preparer does more than just file a form. They protect your money, your records and your peace of mind, and they handle your family's situation with care. Start by confirming a PTIN, asking about credentials and ensuring that fees are agreed in writing. Then look for someone who understands the issues that Black households face.
Get in touch with a Black accountant who understands your community. Submit your details via Heritage Web's secure referral form.
This article is general information, not tax advice. Tax rules change each year; speak with a CPA or enrolled agent about your situation.
Sources
- Census Bureau
- Illinois Department of Revenue
- Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research
- Howard University
- Revenue Procedure 2024-40
- Revenue Procedure 2025-32
- California Tax Education Council
- Oregon Board of Tax Practitioners
- Maryland Department of Labor
- New York State Department of Taxation and Finance
- IRS Criminal Investigation
- Treasury Decision 10035